Discussion about this post

User's avatar
173dVietVet's avatar

What has been proposed here has possibility of success, however I detect that there is no corrective system to deal with, correct, and thereby prevent other mistakes and failures. Perhaps you have some idea on that matter but did not articulate it herein.

I believe that the main failure of Communism has been that there are no sanctions against failure because all in supervisory chain parrot the Party Line ( approved narrative to be followed). When decisions are made upon specious facts that support and hold up the narrative, but the decision fails, nobody who pushed the Party Line can be found at fault to be sanctioned. So nobody is fired/imprisoned/shot due to failure. All such failures then are explained to Party Members as due to insufficient ardor or effort by those at the lowest level, or not enough money was spent to cover the project through to its successful completion. Never can communists blame the Party’s approved but faulty narrative, as being responsible.

Swarms of deciders would appear to be indirectly responsible for a decision that turns out badly. Group dynamics and the need to avoid loss of “face” would make swarm decision makers blend in with each other, and thus dilute individual responsibility for the group’s/swarm’s erroneous decision.

Additionally, swarm decision groups may take way too long to make decisions as each swarmer seeks their own comfort level of input facts which would not coincide with the other swarmers need for sufficient info upon which to base a decision.

The National Treasure known as Thomas Sowell said, “It is hard to imagine a …… more dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong.”

Proof of efficacy could be seen from a test: Town of 5,000 with small fire, police, roads, water/sewer departments. Take 50 citizens to be swarm deciders and make them be the City Commission. Document results. After two years, see how well things have worked. (Note:having spent 22years in such a small town as an official, I think this would be a fair test of your proposal.)

Perhaps some Libertarians like the Koch brothers would financially back this type of test. Best wishes for success ! !

11 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?